Dissecting site-specific functions of O-glycosylation requires simultaneous identification and quantification of differentially expressed O-glycopeptides by mass spectrometry. However, different dissociation methods have not been systematically compared in their performance in terms of identification, glycosite localization, and quantification with isobaric labeling. Here, we conducted this comparison on highly enriched unlabeled O-glycopeptides with higher-energy collision dissociation (HCD), electron-transfer/collision-induced dissociation (ETciD), and electron transfer/higher-energy collisional dissociation (EThcD), concluding that ETciD and EThcD with optimal supplemental activation resulted in superior identification of glycopeptides and unambiguous site localizations than HCD in a database search by Sequest HT. We later described a pseudo-EThcD strategy that in silica concatenates the electron transfer dissociation spectrum with the paired HCD spectrum acquired sequentially for the same precursor ions, which combines the identification advantage of ETciD/EThcD with the superior reporter ion quality of HCD. We demonstrated its improvements in identification and quantification of isobaric mass tag-labeled O-glycopeptides and showcased the discovery of the specific glycosites of GalNAc transferase 11 (GALNT11) in HepG2 cells.